Person giving a five star review on a cell phone

How “Unreasonable Hospitality” Inspired Our Ultimate Secret Shopper Service

/by

I can count the number of books I’ve read more than once on one hand, and Will Guidara’s “Unreasonable Hospitality: The Remarkable Power of Giving People More Than They Expect” is one of them. It’s not just a compelling, deeply personal story about how Guidara and his partner Chef Daniel Humm transformed New York’s Eleven Madison Park into the #1 restaurant on The World’s 50 Best Restaurants list in 2017, but a masterclass in management that can be readily applied to any type of business.

The brilliance of this book lies in how Guidara creates universal takeaways throughout his narrative, all inspired by real-world challenges and moments from Eleven Madison Park’s remarkable journey. The lessons relate not only to how a restaurant or hotel should approach its relationship with team members and guests, but also to operational success, marketing, and PR strategy. Your guests and employees are your frontline ambassadors, each equipped with the ability to broadcast their experience with your brand and ideally inspire others to discover what you’re offering through social media posts or online reviews.

In today’s AI-driven search landscape—where platforms like ChatGPT, Google’s AI Overviews, and voice assistants pull from social media posts, Reddit discussions, customer reviews, and earned media when surfacing your brand—your online reputation carries more weight than ever before.

Key Takeaways from “Unreasonable Hospitality”

Here are the essential lessons from Guidara’s book that apply to any hospitality business:

  • If your business involves making people happy, then you can’t be good at it if you don’t care what people think.
  • Fads fade and cycle, but the human desire to be taken care of never goes away.
  • People will never forget how you made them feel
  • You’re not always going to agree with what you hear, but you’ve got to start by listening.
  • You’re going to mess up. When you do, apologize.
  • If you’ve corrected a guest because you don’t want them to think you’ve made a mistake, you’ve made a much bigger mistake.
  • No aspect of your business should be off-limits to reevaluation.
  • New traditions work only if they’re authentic–if they fill a real purpose and satisfy a real need.
  • When that external affirmation comes, direct it to the people responsible.
  • Treat everyone like a VIP.
  • The value of a gift isn’t about what went into giving it, but how the person receiving it feels.
  • Luxury means just giving more; hospitality means being more thoughtful.
  • The guest’s perception is our reality.

Introducing the Ultimate Secret Shopper

This is precisely why Virginia Miller and I created the Ultimate Secret Shopper service. Inspired by “Unreasonable Hospitality” and Virginia’s unparalleled expertise serving on and leading judging panels and competitions for the world’s best food, drink (spirits, cocktails, wine, non-alcoholic, etc.) restaurants, bars, and hotels, we wanted to ensure Ellipses’ clients have a clear window into what their guests are experiencing.

Once Virginia has a chance to visit unannounced, she delivers  reports from her seasoned perspective as a restaurant and drink critic and international judge that uncover operational blind spots and PR-ready story angles in one stroke. Our goal is to help you level up your service and maximize your authentic and unique strengths to ensure your guests are inspired to tell others about their experience, transforming them into your biggest ambassadors.

The Ultimate Secret Shopper service aligns perfectly with one of Guidara’s core philosophies: the guest’s perception is our reality. By understanding exactly how your service feels from the guest’s perspective, you can identify opportunities to create those memorable “wow” moments that guests can’t stop sharing—the very moments that drive organic word-of-mouth marketing and positive online reviews.

Today’s travelers increasingly rely on AI-powered search to discover their next destination. When ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity can’t find you, neither will tomorrow’s guests. This makes ensuring your reputation reflects the exceptional experience you’re working to deliver more critical than ever. The Ultimate Secret Shopper helps bridge the gap between your intentions and your guests’ actual experience, giving you the insights needed to create the kind of unreasonable hospitality that builds lasting loyalty and drives business growth.

Interested in hearing more about the Ultimate Secret Shopper? Schedule a complimentary discovery call with me.